What Is
Another Curious Incident With Dogs

A Myth (of the Greek kind) and a Legal Ruling (of a vaccine kind)

Charlie and Jim on the beach last Saturday: home sand home, right?  Jim went to Philadelphia yesterday to give a talk to an Irish lawyers group (last week it was the Celtic Medical Society or some such he spoke at---I guess the book isn't titled On the Irish Waterfront for nothing). Charlie and I cooled our heals at home in Jersey, making our usual rounds: driving in different directions on the way home from school; walking 'round the neighborhood; burrowing (Charlie that is) through the refrigerator and cabinets for all available snacks (the New York Times's recent article on "snack time never ends" be darned----boy is hungry, boy eats); typing on my laptop (during which I pondered what Charlie might make of an iPad); gassing up the car so as not to run into the "time to drive to school and then mom to work and the orange 'gas tank is getting empty' light just went on!" problem; stopping at the little local supermarket that has become Charlie's preferred; one more walk in a howling wind (all this wintry walks are turning into an excellent excuse for me to get myself a nice new, and warm, hat); early dinner; early bedtime.

Another day of just what it's like around here.

Inbetween all that (and of course after Charlie was in bed) I read the myth of Demeter, goddess of agriculture, and her daughter Persephone in the Homeric Hymn to Demeter---the Greek myth about how the maiden Persephone is abducted by Hades, god of the Underworld, leading to Demeter falling into mourning her missing child and going in search of her, and letting the crops die and everything growing wither away. Demeter travels down to the Underworld to find Persephone only to learn that, as her daughter has eaten a few seeds of a pomegranate, she can only return to the world above for half the year. And so, it's said, do we have the seasons, spring and summer when Persephone is with her mother, who rejoices, and makes the crops and plants and flowers grow, and autumn and winter when Persephone joins Hades and Demeter withdraws in sorrow.

A couple of years ago when I first started blogging, I referred to this myth in seeking ways to describe how a parent can feel on learning that their child has been diagnosed with autism---that their child's been taken away and, even though the child returns, something is different, it's never the same. 

While I think the myth does capture how a parent feels, I now find the comparison not so just and potentially perilous. Even before the Ransom Notes advertising campaign---in which autism and other childhood psychiatric disorders were portrayed as "kidnappers" who left "ransom notes" threatening dire, empty lives for the children they now had in their clutches---I've never thought that "one day I had a perfectly normal child and then autism came like a thief in the night and took him." The day before and the day after---all the days of his life---Charlie has been Charlie. The diagnosis (Charlie's is, and has always been, "autism") gave clarity in the form of a word that we could write on forms and say to "professionals" to get Charlie therapies, services, into programs.

Whenever I read about Demeter and Persephone, I still find it speaks to me about the love and bond between mother and child, and the terror of loss of each other; about the ache. I guess you could say I've made my views on "recovery from autism" and all of that pretty clear and I'm quite aware (aren't we all, at this point) of the vitriol that gets cast between those who are "one side" of this issue, and those who are "on the other," and those, too, who find themselves in the crossfire. But I do think that one thing that joins all of us parents together is that sometimes we just feel pretty bad, not because we're yearning for the "what if" of a child who's not autistic, but because we're human, things can get really really tough, we don't get enough sleep and just as we're sitting down to read a few pages in a book we come upon some mess needing immediate attention. We just feel bad like any parent who hates to see the child they love unhappy, and we feel it's our parental responsibility to take care of that child. Of our child.

So the news about that Dr. Andrew Wakefield has been found "irresponsible" over the MMR vaccine scare by the General Medical Council; that he "abused a position of trust as he researched a possible link between the MMR vaccine, bowel disease and autism in children" leaves me feeling sad and worn most of all. How much time have we (and I include myself) spent in exchanges about vaccines and autism and Dr. Wakefield himself, exchanges that have taken us far, far away from talking about actual individuals on the autism spectrum and their (in some cases) long-term, life-long needs for services and supports? How many frankly mean, cutting,  things have we flung at each other? How did we let ourselves get so caught up in this controversy that, as it's gradually developing, indeed has less and less to do with autism?

Because all those parents who believed Dr. Wakefield and his theories about a "link" between vaccines and autism----because we all love our kids and, like Demeter, would travel to the ends of the earth to help them.

You don't need me to tell you that love is foolish, that love makes you proverbially blind, makes some things you might look back on and question yourself about. 

Emily has a list of media and blog responses to the news about Dr. Wakefield and the GMC. (LB/RB of course already has a couple of posts and, on the other end of the spectrum on this issue, is AOA.) I suspect the divisions of belief, and the contentious exchanges, will continue. Certainly it would be nice if we could end the autism wars---but somehow it seems near-impossible to stop "looking in whatever direction we think most important at the moment," so that we "let our understanding of what binds us together atrophy."

Accordingly, while unable to resist an occasional dip into those more contentious waters, I'll be looking homeward most of all, and boyward. Because, this is what it's all about.



I'm glad you'll be looking homeward most of all, and I'm trying to do the same myself. Although there needs to be research and debate, the arguments and philosophies can end up distracting from what is right in front of us - our lives, our children.

Been looking at some iPad reviews, I'm wondering how sturdy it is (probably not sturdy enough).

I live in Greece but am learning more about Greek myths right here :) I was beating a pomegranate with a wooden spoon last night to get the seeds out and trying to remember their meaning in art.


You might be interested in the wide variety of Changeling myths dating from the Middle Ages. They primarily come from Celtic/German sources. http://www.pitt.edu/~dash/gerchange.html
The changeling, left by trolls or gnomes in the place of the "real" child, has a large head, staring eyes, and does nothing but eat, drink, sleep. Sometimes it smashes all the things in the house.

It's been hypothesized that the myth of the Changeling was a medieval rationale for autism. Kim Duff gave a paper on "The Role of Changeling Lore in Autistic Culture" presentation at the 1999 Autreat conference of Autism Network International.

sarah schuman

Kristina---- well said.

We need to have researchers and physicians focus on how to help treat our autistic children rather than trying to find a "cure or link". I know down the road they may find out what causes autism; however right now I need services and therapy suggestions for my son's "storms" and day to day living.

It always amazes me how many people who find out that my son is autistic ask if he has been vaccinated. I have forced myself to look forward rather than backwards and continue on the journey of taking care of my son.

Yes, there will and are huge bumps in the road, but focusing our energy on "repair" work is what is needed right now, today in the moment. What I mean by repair is getting though the next few minutes to the next couple of hours----.
Enjoy living in the moment....many dont choose to do that! :)


Nice post, Kristina. Atrophy of all that is good and decent seems endemic in our society now.


I was going to add my two cents about the "changeling" myth but I see Louise beat me to it.
One thing I like about the Demeter/Persephone myth is that the "blame" for Persephone's disappearance is not laid on her mother but on an outside agency, one that neither mother nor child caused or "Invited," if we're talking about the Lord of the Underworld, either real or metaphorical.
It's true that autism is on the rise, alarmingly so. SOMETHING is causing it and if it's not refrigerator mothers or vaccines then what is it? Our world is full of chemicals and poisons. Our meat is pumped full of hormones and our bread is full of preservatives. In our greed and ignorance we have been very cruel to our mother earth, or Gaia, if you prefer.
Something needs to be done to prevent any further breakdown in the health of our planet.


"How did we let ourselves get so caught up in this controversy that, as it's gradually developing, indeed has less and less to do with autism?"

No kidding.

Good thoughts. I like those photos of you and Charlie and hearing about your day. Ours was good too. Hope tomorrow is as well.
Warm regards.


I'm with you...I'll push for looking at the atrophied legs rather than the broken little toe. There are so many things wrong with the way society deals with autism; we are but maggots arguing over the elephant carcass...

Kristina Chew

....flies buzzing round the dead horse of Athens, to quote someone famous........


Umm, ain't Ceres in there somewhere? I like cereals, when I can't afford meat and vegetables.

Kristina Chew

Yup, Ceres = Demeter, among the Romans.

I'm one of those "autism and genetics" persons and think better diagnosis and more understanding, and a cultural climate that is more accepting about disability and difference, have much to do with the increase in the autism rate.


I've been somewhat wary of the changeling stories when applied to autism---one reason why I became less sure about writing about the Demeter/Persephone myth.


---and here's Amanda Baggs on the topic of "changeling stereotypes":


I've been tempted to buy some pomegranate seeds (already beaten out of the fruit) a few times but then I've been leery of the stains! As for the iPad, there's a lot of sticky fingers around here (leaving some artful smudges on this laptop screen), wonder if that would gum up the works.....

Liz Ditz

Your usual lovely and evocative post.

If you want an exhaustive list of blog posts on the Wakefield decision, both from folk continuing to support Wakefield and those lauding the GMC verdicts, come on over to my blog.

I don't know if you read Bev at Asperger's Square 8 very regularly. Today's post is on the topic of curing autism. I found it very moving.

Liz Ditz

Oops. I see that imbedded links don't work.

My Wakefield roundup post:


Bev's post


Kristina Chew

In my fantasy autism blogger panel, AspergerSquare8 is a top pick!

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)